The first step was making a marinade — made of buttermilk, a jalapeño, a shallot, two cloves of garlic, and salt and pepper — for the chicken breasts.

This step was simple, as nothing was more difficult than smashing the garlic or slicing the shallots.

I was more nervous about the next part — flattening three 6-ounce chicken breasts into wider, flatter cutlets.

My local supermarket offered a variety of chicken breast cuts, and since I generally try to avoid doing too much involving raw chicken in my cramped kitchen, I found myself wishing Garten had called for a pre-prepared cut like thin-cut breasts or tenderloins.

Instead, I followed the recipe, laying the chicken breasts between two pieces of parchment paper and pounding them with a rolling pin until they were evenly half-an-inch thick.

This proved surprisingly easy and not nearly as messy as I feared — just a minute or two of whacking at the chicken yielded three flat, evenly sized pieces.

Once the chicken breasts were flattened, I cut them in half and added them to the marinade.

Garten’s recipe said to cover the marinade in plastic wrap, but I transferred it to a reusable container because it seemed like it would be neater and more environmentally friendly.

The chicken marinated overnight in my refrigerator until I was ready to make and eat the sandwiches the next day.

Next, I made Garten’s buttermilk-herb mayo, a mixture of mayo, buttermilk, vinegar, scallions, parsley, chives, and thyme.

With the chicken fully marinated and the herb mayo complete, it was time to batter and fry the chicken.

Using a Dutch oven and a thermometer, I heated 2 inches worth of canola oil to 350-degrees Fahrenheit.

The flour mixture was easy to make, and included baking soda, smoked paprika, cayenne pepper, celery salt, salt, and black pepper.

The recipe calls for double-dredging: each piece of chicken alternates between the marinade and the flour mixture twice before being placed in the oil to cook.

Here, my choice of reusable plastic container made things more difficult. The container was fairly shallow, and as flour from the first dredge thickened the marinade, it got harder to submerge the chicken before the second dredge.

The recipe called for frying each piece of chicken for five minutes, turning once. I followed the instructions and kept my oil at 350 degrees throughout.

However, I found that five minutes of frying produced a darker crust than what was shown on the chicken in Garten’s photos. I could have tried pulling it sooner, but I was concerned the chicken inside wouldn’t be fully cooked.

Once the chicken was out of the fryer, I constructed the sandwiches by slathering potato buns with the herb mayo. Then, I added lettuce, sliced pickles, and the finished chicken cutlets.

As a whole, these sandwiches were very good, but the chicken itself was the clear highlight. There wasn’t a ton of spice to it, despite the jalapeño in the marinade and the cayenne in the dredge, but there was just enough to make it tasty and to balance the sweetness of the potato bun.

The texture of the chicken was fantastic — the breading was nice and crispy and the chicken was incredibly moist. Plus, the lettuce and pickles gave the sandwich some crunch and some tanginess.

I had leftover fried chicken cutlets afterwards, and I was pleased to find they maintained both their moisture and their crispness when reheated in the air fryer.

However, both my wife and I agreed the buttermilk-herb mayo mostly just tasted like mayonnaise. While we were eating the sandwiches, we found ourselves speculating about other sauces that would go better with the chicken and require less effort.

The only other downsides were that the double-dredging and frying left my kitchen a mess, and my whole apartment smelled strongly of oil for about the next 24 hours.

So, although I enjoyed the sandwiches, I can’t imagine preparing them for guests unless I somehow come into a much larger home with a much airier kitchen.

But since the chicken cutlets themselves were a hit, I will likely use that portion of the recipe again. Next time, I’ll skip the mayonnaise and double the chicken, since I know it keeps and reheats fairly well.