I was so excited to work with a new client.
Perfect for my expertise and the type of company I prefer to work with. Meeting the client for an exploratory call felt like a dream. A well-respected brand to add to my portfolio.
But once the contract was signed, it was a struggle from Day 1. We parted ways six months later.
Most advice about struggling client relationships assumes there is an obvious problem, like that the client is overly demanding or hard to reach. But in this case, it was something else. The vibes were off. When that happens, it’s less obvious what to fix.
Recognizing the difference between a difficult client and a poor fit can help you decide sooner whether to adjust the working relationship or simply walk away.
Why a client can look right on paper and still not work
The things I vet for during the sales process can be different from the things that make a working relationship successful.
Before signing, I look at the potential client’s industry and the scope of work. The client’s budget has to be aligned with my rate, and I have to feel confident that I can deliver what the client is asking for. That’s the relationship “on paper.”
But what’s often unknown is how the client interacts with a consultant or contractor (like me). I’m also unaware of any internal politics at the company that might impact the working relationship. Those details usually become apparent once I start delivering actual work.
Is it a difficult client or a poor fit?
A difficult client has problems like not paying on time or asking for work outside of the scope. These can be fixed (or at least managed) with a solid contract and clear boundaries. Most of the biggest client red flags solopreneurs face are in this category.
A poor fit is different. The client may pay on time and stay within scope, but other parts of the working relationship feel strained. Maybe stakeholder feedback gets under your skin because of how it’s presented. Or you find yourself dreading the work, even though, on paper, it’s what you had agreed to do.
One thing to ask yourself: Would a different consultant or contractor have the same trouble with this client? If the answer is yes, you’re likely dealing with a difficult client. But if you can picture someone else doing great work for them, the problem is probably fit.
A second question: If this client always pays on time and never asked for anything outside of scope, would you still want the work? A “no” usually means fit is the issue.
What to try before you walk away
A poor fit sometimes might improve if you’re able to directly address the thing that’s causing you angst. It’s worth trying before you decide.
If the problem is, for example, “too many cooks” providing you with feedback and contradictory opinions, you might be able to solve this. Something like:
“It’s easier for me to make sure I deliver what you need if you consolidate your feedback. Can you work on your end to send me a list of thoughts/changes? That way, I don’t start down one path only to find that you want me to go in a different direction.”
In some cases, your client might be willing to change — they may simply not have experience working with a contractor or consultant.
You might also give yourself a checkpoint, like an additional month of work after the conversation. If nothing has changed by then, you have your answer.
Admitting the relationship isn’t working
When you work solo, a poor fit can drag you down. In a company, a colleague might take over the account, or a manager could reassign the work. As a solopreneur, there’s no one to hand it to. And since your income depends on the work, ending the relationship means replacing that revenue.
But staying has a cost. Stress. Frustration. All the things you were supposed to escape by choosing a solopreneur life instead of a corporate job.
If the conversation with your client doesn’t change anything, more effort probably won’t fix it. At that point, calling it a poor fit and moving on is a business decision.
It helps to remember that a poor fit says nothing about your skills or the client’s character. It simply didn’t work out.